Sr. Ell et al., MICROBIAL COLONIZATION OF THE GRONINGEN SPEAKING VALVE AND ITS RELATIONSHIP TO VALVE FAILURE, Clinical otolaryngology and allied sciences, 20(6), 1995, pp. 555-556
Speaking valve failure may be related to biofilm development. An inter
-observer validated method of assessing microbial overgrowth in defect
ive prostheses was developed. Two independent observers recorded colon
isation of the valves on a 100 mm linear analogue scale in several def
ined areas. Interobserver agreement was high in all areas. In vitro op
ening pressure and derived forward resistances were measured. The rela
tionship between colonization of the valves and the in vitro measureme
nts was investigated. Significant correlations for a two-tailed Spearm
an's test were recorded between the resistance and microbial colonizat
ion of the hinge and oesophageal areas (r(s), 0.22: P < 0.05, r(s) 0.2
5: P < 0.05, n = 80). There was no significant association for resista
nce and colonization of the tracheal surface, and no significant assoc
iation between the opening pressure and the colonization. This work su
ggests that microbial colonization of the prosthesis in the oesophagea
l and hinge areas is associated with valve failure.