We quantified variability in daily settlement of blue crab postlarvae
(megalopae) on identical artificial settlement substrates at up to 6 s
ites concurrently over a broad geographic expanse (similar to 1300 km)
of the western North Atlantic (Delaware-South Carolina, USA). The 4-y
ear study encompassed the blue crab recruitment season (generally July
-November) from 1989-1992. Regional settlement was characterized by: (
1) constant low levels of daily settlement punctuated by significantly
non-random, episodic peaks of variable duration and intensity with pe
aks collectively accounting for at least half the total annual settlem
ent at a site; (2) spatial and temporal variability leading to a gener
al lack of coherence between sites in a given year and across years wi
thin a site; (3) occasional coherence in patterns between sites during
a given year, suggesting linkages in regional processes affecting set
tlement; and, (4) significant semilunar patterns of episodic settlemen
t pulses at the York River and Charleston-Harbor sites over a 4-year p
eriod. Thus, regional settlement patterns exhibit both consistent (i.e
., semilunar periodicity, episodic pulses) and variable (i.e., tempora
l and spatial variation) elements, which are likely due to a combinati
on of stochastic and deterministic processes. Such patterns may impart
an ecological advantage to crabs settling en masse (i.e., reduced enc
ounter rate with predators through predator swamping) or at continuous
low levels (i.e., below a density-dependent threshold) during the rec
ruitment season. An identical study illustrated that settlement in Gul
f of Mexico estuaries exhibited similarly episodic and highly variable
patterns. Daily mean and total annual settlement were up to a hundred
-fold greater for gulf than Atlantic Coast estuaries implying populati
on limitation by post-settlement processes in the gulf and greater rec
ruitment limitation in the Atlantic. These studies emphasize the merit
of conducting research over a broad geographic range using standardiz
ed techniques to attempt meaningful ecological comparisons.