The move from theorizing difference to dealing with difference in an i
ntercultural collaboration creates generative conflicts for educators
and students. This article tracks the conflicting discourses, alternat
ive representations, and political consequences the construct ''Black
English'' had for Black and White mentors, teenage writers, and instru
ctors in a Community Literacy Center collaboration. Comparing the acco
unts offered by resistance, conversation, and negotiation theory it ex
amines the dilemma-driven process of constructing a new negotiated mea
ning in the face of conflicting forces, voices, and representations. D
ealing with difference in such collaboration means not only interpreti
ng diverse verbal and nonverbal signifying systems based on values, ex
perience, and competing discourses but constructing a new negotiated r
epresentation in the face of conflict that offers an (at least provisi
onal) ground for action.