A recent World Bank study comes to optimistic conclusions about the im
pact of adjustment on African industry and exports. This paper questio
ns both the underlying approach and the empirical evidence. The analys
is on which adjustment programs are based ignores market failures in t
he process of developing competitive capabilities. The data do not est
ablish that adjustment benefited industry. The experience of Ghana, th
e strongest adjuster in Africa, shows a spurt followed by relative sta
gnation and little manufactured export diversification. Accepting the
desirability of openness and policy reform, the policy needs that emer
ge are very different from those of Bank adjustment programs.