COMPARISON OF GALLIUM-67-CITRATE AND TL-201 SCINTIGRAPHY IN PERIPHERAL AND INTRATHORACIC LYMPHOMA

We performed this study in an attempt to reconcile the differences wit h respect to Ga-67 uptake as a function of tumor grade and type in the literature, as well as to determine the sensitivity of (TI)-T-201 upt ake in both Hodgkin's and non-Hodgkin's lymphoma, Methods: Thirty-six (9 with low-grade lymphoma, 11 with intermediate-grade lymphoma, 4 wit h high-grade lymphoma and 12 with Hodgkin's lymphoma) patients underwe nt both Ga-67 and (TI)-T-201 scintigraphy, Biopsies were done on all p atients. A semiquantitative rating system was used to make statistical comparisons for thallium versus gallium in all lymphoma subgroups, as well as comparisons of thallium and gallium to themselves in all subg roups. Results: Patient sensitivity was only 56% and site sensitivity was 32% in patients with low-grade lymphoma. Conversely, (TI)-T-201 se nsitivity was 100%, respectively, for patients and sites. The differen ce between (TI)-T-201 and Ga-67 sensitivity in patients with low-grade lymphoma on a site basis was statistically significant. When compared to itself in lymphoma subgroups, (TI)-T-201 was found to be statistic ally more avid for low-grade lymphoma than for intermediate, high or H odgkin's lymphoma. Gallium-67 sensitivity for low-grade lymphoma was s ignificantly less than for Hodgkin's and intermediate grade lymphomas. No significant differences were found when (TI)-T-201 and Ga-67 were compared in the intermediate, high or Hodgkin's lymphoma groups. Concl usion: Thallium-201 demonstrates significantly greater tumor avidity i n the low-grade lymphoma group compared to Ga-67 citrate. Gallium-67-c itrate appears relatively nonavid for low-grade lymphoma compared to ( TI)-T-201 and is statistically inferior in detecting low-grade lymphom a in comparison to its ability to detect intermediate or high-grade ly mphomas. Gallium-67-citrate should not be considered dependable in eva luating patients with low-grade lymphoma. Neither (TI)-T-201 or Ga-67 is dependable in the evaluation of low-grade lymphoma within the abdom en, since gallium avidity for low-grade lymphoma is low and gastrointe stinal excretion of (TI)-T-201 is poorly controlled.