Re. Harmer et al., LEAD-ISOTOPE VARIATIONS WITHIN THE BUSHVELD COMPLEX, SOUTHERN AFRICA - A RECONNAISSANCE STUDY, Journal of African earth sciences, and the Middle East, 21(4), 1995, pp. 595-606
Variations in initial Sr-87/Sr-86 through the mafic cumulates of the B
ushveld complex have long been used to trace the nature and relative i
nfluence of different parental liquids in the development of the magma
chamber. The authors report the results of the first systematic inves
tigation of the lead isotopic variation in the complex and provide inf
ormation on both silicate and sulphide phases through the cumulate suc
cession. Marginal and cumulate lithologies indicate that the initial l
ead isotopic composition (represented by model source U-238/Pb-204 rat
ios) varies systematically in a manner analogous to that detected with
strontium isotopic ratios. Low mu(2) ratios are evident in the Lower
Zone and increase up the cumulate pile to the Main Zone, which apparen
tly had homogeneous initial lead isotopic ratios. Unlike Sr-87/Sr-86,
however, considerable mu(2) variation is detected in the Upper Zone. C
umulate lithologies also exhibit a greater range of mu(2) values than
those noted in the Marginal suite representatives, comparable to the s
ituation for strontium isotopes. Most of the model mu(2) results are h
igher than values expected for mantle-derived magmas, suggesting the i
ncorporation of material with a crustal pre-history. Analyses of a det
ailed sampling of the Merensky and Bastard cyclic units at the Atok mi
ne, eastern Bushveld are also presented and these reveal extreme value
s of mu(2) while the variations in mu 2 do not mirror the Sr-87/Sr-86
variations reported for the same samples by Lee and Butcher (1990). El
evated mu(2) in some cumulate samples are impossibly high for a magmat
ic origin and presumably reflect the introduction of extra-magmatic co
mponents during sub-solidus hydrothermal alteration.