In this in vitro study, we compared the potential of collagen and algi
nate gels as carriers for chondrocyte transplantation and we studied t
he influence of demineralized bone matrix (DBM) on chondrocytes in the
gels. Chondrocytes were assessed for cell viability, phenotype (histo
logy), proliferation rate and sulfate incorporation. Collagen gels sho
wed a significant increase in cell numbers, but the chondrocytes dedif
ferentiated into fibroblast-like cells from day 6 onwards. In alginate
gels, initial cell loss was found, but the cells maintained their typ
ical chondrocyte phenotype. Although the total quantity of proteoglyca
ns initially synthesized per cell in collagen gel was significantly hi
gher, expressed per cell, the quantity in alginate gel eventually surp
assed collagen. No effects of culturing chondrocytes in combination wi
th DBM could be demonstrated on cell proliferation and sulfate incorpo
ration. The collagen and alginate gels have different advantages as ca
rriers for chondrocyte transplantation. The high proliferation rate of
chondrocytes in collagen gel may be an advantage, but the preservatio
n of the chondrocyte phenotype and the gradually increasing proteoglyc
an synthesis in alginate gel is a promising method for creating a hyal
ine cartilage implant in vitro.