M. Curic et D. Janc, ON THE SENSITIVITY OF THE CONTINUOUS ACCRETION RATE-EQUATION USED IN BULK-WATER PARAMETERIZATION SCHEMES, Atmospheric research, 39(4), 1995, pp. 313-332
The analytical solutions of the continuous accretion rate equation are
compared regarding two different size distributions for cloud and rai
n water, two hail terminal velocities for different turbulent regimes
and two solution types. The Khrgian-Mazin and Marshall-Palmer size dis
tributions are assumed for rain water fraction, while the Khrgian-Mazi
n and monodisperse ones are applied to cloud water. In all cases the e
xponential-type size distribution for hail is used. In the calculation
procedure for hail terminal velocity we take into consideration that
the drag coefficient may be fixed or dependent on Reynolds number. Bot
h approximate and exact solutions of the accretion rate under the same
other conditions are also compared. Results show that the Khrgian-Maz
in size distribution makes the approximate accretion rate between hail
and rain considerably higher compared to its former parameterization
for both hail terminal velocity assumptions. On the other side, the ne
w treatment of hail terminal velocity with a variable drag coefficient
produces lower accretion rates compared to the fixed drag coefficient
case for all size distributions used. The approximate solution of the
accretion rate equation is mainly lower than the exact one. Only in t
he case of raindrops-cloud droplets interaction it is much higher than
the exact one with the Khrgian-Mazin size distribution used.