By focusing on the family economy and its capacity to mediate broad ec
onomic developments, sociologists are beginning to move beneath macros
tructural forces to better explain parental demand for schooling and c
hildren's attainment. This materialist model focuses on the explanator
y power of contextual labor demand and resources internal to the famil
y. Parents' social preferences and commitments, antecedent to ''choosi
ng'' between work or school for their children, are presumed to covary
with economic factors. In contrast, research on family practices with
in impoverished settings reveals that parents' social commitments link
ed to child development or schooling can vary independently of the fam
ily's economic circumstances. Applying these alternative theories to f
amily behavior in southern African, we assess the relative influence o
f mothers' economic demands and social commitments on their daughter's
probability of staying in school. We find that the risk of daughters
leaving school is more strongly influenced by mothers' social commitme
nts than by household economics. Maternal influences do interact with
selected family-economy indicators and are conditioned by the level of
discretionary time afforded to daughters.