Jg. Dumesnil et al., A NEW, SIMPLE AND ACCURATE METHOD FOR DETERMINING EJECTION FRACTION BY DOPPLER-ECHOCARDIOGRAPHY, Canadian journal of cardiology, 11(11), 1995, pp. 1007-1014
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the feasibility, accuracy and reproducibility o
f a new and simple method for determining ejection fraction by Doppler
echocardiography. This method should theoretically be less influenced
by the distortions of left ventricular geometry caused by prior myoca
rdial infraction, DESIGN: Two groups of patients (total 114) were eval
uated independently at the Quebec and Ottawa Heart Institutes (60 and
54 patients, respectively). All were referred for radionuclide angiogr
aphy performed within 24 h of the echocardiogram. Regional asynergy wa
s present in 59% of Quebec patients and 37% of Ottawa patients. The ne
w method for calculating ejection fraction consisted of dividing Doppl
er derived stroke volume in the left ventricular outflow tract by left
ventricular end-diastolic volume calculated by Teichholz's formula ;
for comparison, ejection fraction was also measured by single plane ar
ea length or multiple disc planimetry as well as by the Quinones metho
d at the Quebec Heart Institute. RESULTS: Feasibility of the new metho
d was 97% in Quebec and 100% in Ottawa. Compared with radionuclide ang
iography, the correction coefficient for the new method was 0.92 (stan
dard error of estimate [SEE] = 7.3) in Quebec compared with 0.88 (SEE
= 8.5 and 8.1) for both the Quinones and single plane area length meth
ods, and 0.84 (SEE 12.0) in Ottawa compared with 0.77 (SEE = 10.9) for
the single plane multiple disc method. Corrections in patients with r
egional asynergy were 0.90 in Quebec and 0.75 in Ottawa compared with
0.81 and 0.54 with planimetry. Correction coefficients for interobserv
er variability in 12 patients were 0.97 with the new method compared w
ith 0.88 with the Quinones method and 0.85 with single plane planimetr
y. CONCLUSION: This new and simple method is feasible, accurate and re
producible even in patients with regional asynergy. Provided there is
no significant mitral regurgitation, it is a time-saving alternative f
or the routine evaluation of ejection fraction by Doppler echocardiogr
aphy.