K. Gupta et al., DELIBERATE SELF-HARM - A COMPARISON OF FIRST-TIME CASES AND CASES WITH A PRIOR HISTORY, Irish journal of psychological medicine, 12(4), 1995, pp. 131-134
Objective: Eighty one patients admitted following deliberate self-harm
were assessed using a semistructured interview, The aim of the study
was to compare clinical and social profiles of the 42 patients who had
committed self harm for the first time with those of the 39 who had c
ommitted self harm in the past. Method: The patients were assessed joi
ntly by a psychiatrist and either a community psychiatric nurse or a s
ocial worker, A description of past suicidal behaviour, socio demograp
hic information, medical and psychiatric history were recorded. Suicid
e intent was assessed both from the clinical interview and rated objec
tively using Pierce's suicide intent scale, Psychiatric diagnoses were
made using the ICD 9 classification. Results: The entire group had ex
perienced difficulties in sustaining relationships, This problem was s
ignificantly more widespread in repeaters with increased use of physic
al violence in their relationship. More patients with a previous histo
ry claimed to have death wishes at the time of self harm, and asserted
that they would harm themselves again compared with patients without
a previous history, Clinical predictions regarding future self harming
behaviour were in line with the patient's stated intentions. Conclusi
on: The persistent desire to commit self harm and more widespread rela
tional difficulties amongst the patients with a previous history sugge
sts a need for different treatment strategies and outcome measures for
the two groups.