Rs. Legro et al., ASSOCIATION OF EARLY BETA-HUMAN CHORIONIC-GONADOTROPIN VALUES WITH PREGNANCY WASTAGE AND MULTIPLE IMPLANTATION IN A DONOR OOCYTE PROGRAM, Human reproduction, 10(12), 1995, pp. 3293-3296
An early marker predictive of a viable pregnancy would ease the anxiet
y associated with positive pregnancy tests after the use of donor oocy
tes. We examined the predictive value of an early serum quantitative h
uman chorionic gonadotrophin (Q-HCG) concentration on pregnancy outcom
e following oocyte donation. Embryo transfers after oocyte donation re
sulting in a positive serum beta-HCG were examined beginning 9 days af
ter embryo transfer from those samples assayed in our laboratory (n =
77). Q-HCG concentrations were measured in our laboratory by an immuno
radiometric assay utilizing the first International Reference Preparat
ion. Implantations were defined as the number of gestational sacs visu
alized by transvaginal ultrasound 21 days after embryo transfer. Bioch
emical pregnancies were those with transient elevations in beta-HCG co
ncentration but without implantation sites. Spontaneous abortions were
characterized by an implantation site with the eventual arrest of dev
elopment. Ongoing/delivered pregnancies developed appropriately and pr
oceeded beyond the first trimester. Day 9 Q-HCG concentrations did not
differentiate between biochemical pregnancies/ spontaneous abortions
and ongoing/delivered pregnancies, although mean +/- SD concentrations
for biochemical pregnancies were significantly lower than those for t
he other groups (P < 0.0001): biochemical pregnancies, n = 18, 5.8 +/-
8.9 mIU/ml, range 0-35; spontaneous abortions, n = 2, 46.0 +/- 10.0 m
IU/ml, range 39-53; ongoing/delivered pregnancies, n = 57, 41.5 +/- 35
.4 mIU/ml, range 0-214. In addition, day 9 Q-HCG concentrations did no
t differentiate between multiple implantations, although the implantat
ion of four sacs had a significantly higher mean Q-HCG concentration c
ompared with the implantation of fewer sacs (P < 0.0001): one sac, n =
22, 32.2 +/- 21.5 mIU/ml, range 3-78; two sacs, n = 25, 35.8 +/- 21.3
, range 0-81; three sacs, n = 7, 47.1 +/- 37.1 mIU/ml, range 22-126; f
our sacs, n = 4, 122.3 +/- 62.4 mIU/ml, range 76-214. The positive pre
dictive value of a Q-HCG > 10 mIU/ml was 0.91 (sensitivity 91%, specif
icity 75%). These initial data suggest that early day 9 serum Q-HCG de
terminations do not accurately identify viable pregnancies or multiple
implantations. Even an early negative pregnancy test Should be repeat
ed because it can be associated with a normal pregnancy.