M. Wilson et al., CONTRASTING FRACTIONATION TRENDS IN COEXISTING CONTINENTAL ALKALINE MAGMA SERIES - CANTAL, MASSIF-CENTRAL, FRANCE, Journal of Petrology, 36(6), 1995, pp. 1729-1753
Two coexisting series of strongly alkaline (basanite-tephrite-phonolit
e) and weakly alkaline (alkali basalt-trachyandesite-trachyte-rhyolite
) lavas occur in the Cantal volcano (French Massif Central). The paren
tal magmas appear to be derived by variable degrees of partial melting
of a common asthenospheric mantle source. Derivative trachyandesites
and feldspathoid-bearing tephrites show depletions and enrichments in
trace elements which indicate that they have been generated by broadly
similar fractionation processes, related to the removal of a mineral
extract, from the parental alkali basalts and basanites respectively,
dominated by, olivine, clinopyroxene, amphibole, apatite and titanifer
ous magnetite +/- plagioclase. In the most extreme differentiates (tra
chytes, rhyolites and phonolites) fractionation of zircon, sphene and
alkali feldspar exerts a major control an the trace element characteri
stics of the magmas. Sr-Nd-Pb isotopic data for the two magma series s
uggest the importance of combined assimilation-fractional crystallizat
ion processes (AFC) within the lower crust in their evolution. Modelli
ng demonstrates that the AFC process amplifies the original compositio
nal differences between the parent magmas. After similar to 55% crysta
llization in the strongly alkaline series and 65% in the weakly alkali
ne series crustal contamination ceases, although fractional crystallis
ation continues beyond this point to produce the most evolved differen
tiates (phonolites and rhyolites). This may reflect progressive sealin
g of the lower-crustal magma reservoirs. The tendency of the magmas to
follow over- or under-saturated evolutionary trends, producing rhyoli
tic and phonolitic residua respectively, appears to be established at
the early stages of magmatic differentiation, reflecting inherent diff
erences in the compositions of the parental magmas.