On the basis of nonlinear time-series analysis of vole data, Turchin (
1993) proposed that there is a latitudinal shift from stability to cha
os in the dynamics of vole populations. Falck et al. (1995) question s
everal aspects of the approach I used. In particular, they point out t
hat no measure of uncertainty has been calculated for each point estim
ate of the dominant Lyapunov exponent (a positive Lyapunov exponent im
plies chaos, while a negative one implies stability). In this note I r
espond to the criticisms of Falck et al. (1995). As part of my respons
e, I analyse fluctuations of pooled numbers of microtine rodents at al
l European locations for which I currently have data. Treating each ge
ographic location as a replicate, I show that the mean Lyapunov expone
nt is significantly greater than zero in northern populations (latitud
e greater than 60 degrees N).