RESULTS OF ALLOGENEIC BONE-MARROW TRANSPLANTATION FOR ACUTE-LEUKEMIA HAVE IMPROVED IN EUROPE WITH TIME - A REPORT OF THE ACUTE-LEUKEMIA WORKING PARTY OF THE EUROPEAN GROUP FOR BLOOD AND MARROW TRANSPLANTATION (EBMT)
F. Frassoni et al., RESULTS OF ALLOGENEIC BONE-MARROW TRANSPLANTATION FOR ACUTE-LEUKEMIA HAVE IMPROVED IN EUROPE WITH TIME - A REPORT OF THE ACUTE-LEUKEMIA WORKING PARTY OF THE EUROPEAN GROUP FOR BLOOD AND MARROW TRANSPLANTATION (EBMT), Bone marrow transplantation, 17(1), 1996, pp. 13-18
To evaluate whether the results of bone marrow transplantation have im
proved in Europe with time, we analyzed the outcome for 2195 patients
with acute leukemia. 1405 had acute myeloid leukemia (AML) and 790 had
acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL), and were allografted in first com
plete remission between September 1979 and December 1991 with marrow f
rom an HLA-identical sibling donor. We found a continuing improvement
more evident since 1987 for AML and since 1986 for ALL. A substantial
reduction in the 3 years transplant related mortality (TRM): 26 vs 39%
for AML (P=10(-4)), and 25 vs 39% for ALL (P=10(-4)), has resulted in
an increase of the 5-year actuarial leukemia-free survival (LFS). 57
vs 45% for AML (P < 10(-4)) and 54 vs 45% (P = 10(-4)) for ALL. Four i
mportant changes have occurred. (1) Graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) p
revention has involved an increased use of cyclosporin A (CsA) alone a
nd subsequently its use in combination with methotrexate: this was ass
ociated with lower TRM both in AML and ALL; (2) Use of total body irra
diation as pretransplant regimen has decreased; (3) a shorter interval
from remission to BMT is more common; (4) an older population of pati
ents has undergone BMT. Multivariate analyses were performed separatel
y in AML and ALL. In AML four variables significantly influenced TRM f
avorably: year of BMT (P=10(-4)), younger age at BMT (P=10(-4)), preve
ntion of GVHD including CsA (P=0.008), sex match other than female don
or to male recipient (P=0.002). The relapse incidence (RI) was lower i
n patients with FAB M1-2-3 vs M4-5 (P=0.0004). The LFS improved by yea
r of BMT (P=0.0004), younger age at BMT (P=10(-4)), prevention of GVHD
including CsA (P=0.01), FAB M1-2-3 (P=0.03). In ALL, three variables
were associated with a fewer TRM: year of BMT (P=10(-4)), younger age
at BMT (P=10(-4)), sex combination other than female to male (P=0.008)
. The LFS was better after 1986 (P=0.0004) and in younger patients (P=
10(-4)). However a better outcome after 1986/87 was observed in patien
ts receiving the same GVHD prophylaxis: therefore, other unidentified
factors resulting in better patient care have also contributed to this
. The improved results of allogeneic BMT are entirely related to a red
uction in TRM without loss of the antileukemic effect since relapse in
cidence has not changed over the years.