Dc. Aronson et al., RENAL-CELL CARCINOMA IN CHILDHOOD AND ADOLESCENCE - A RETROSPECTIVE SURVEY FOR PROGNOSTIC FACTORS IN 22 CASES, Journal of pediatric surgery, 31(1), 1996, pp. 183-186
dTo identify prognostic factors for renal carcinoma in young patients,
a retrospective analysis was performed of 22 patients (less than or e
qual to 21 years of age) with histologically verified renal cell carci
noma. Demographic, staging, and treatment variables were collected in
a database, and their effect on survival was determined using Kaplan M
eier probability distribution. The median age was 15.5 years (range, 3
to 21 years), and the male:female ratio was 13:9. Only three patients
were black. Histopathologic examination showed 15 clear cell tumors,
4 mixed cell type, 2 papillary, and one well-differentiated adenocarci
noma. The median size of the primary tumor was 10 cm (range, 5 to 20).
There were seven patients with stage I tumors, one with stage II, and
14 with stage IV. Complete resection of the primary tumor was accompl
ished in 12 patients. The overall B-year survival rate was 30% (confid
ence interval, 20% to 40%). The 5-year survival rate was better for pa
tients who had complete resection of the primary tumor (60% v 10%). Un
resectability was associated with involvement of nodes and/or occur re
nce of metastases, thus an independent effect of complete resection on
survival could not be demonstrated. The data showed that age, tumor s
ize, location, and histology were not predictors of outcome; tumor sta
ge and complete surgical resection were the only meaningful prognostic
factors. The presentation of renal cell carcinoma as a localized or s
ystemic disease may reflect a twofold biological behavior. In the firs
t group, the disease is curable with resection, in the second, it is u
naffected by surgery or adjuvant therapy. In light of the very low inc
idence of this renal malignancy in childhood, prospective multicenter
studies will be required to improve the poor therapeutic results. Copy
right (C) 1996 by W.B. Saunders Company.