Background - A decline in host resistance due to an alteration in diet
- primarily of salt - was recently put forward as a possible explanat
ion for rising rates of asthma. Methods - A case-control study was cod
ucted in participants in a prevalence survey which included 187 childr
en with asthma (defined by prior diagnosis and/or a decline in forced
expiratory volume in one second (FEV(1)) of greater than or equal to 1
0% after exercise) and 145 age and sex matched controls. Subjects were
selected from 989 children aged 5-13 years attending 18 elementary sc
hools on the island of Montreal. Usual dietary salt intake was estimat
ed from a food frequency questionnaire administered to the mother, and
a salt intake score was used to group the children into quartiles fro
m I (lowest) to IV (highest salt intake). Bronchial hyperresponsivenes
s to methacholine was assessed by Yan's method. Cases and controls wer
e combined in one group to examine the relationship of salt intake to
bronchial hyperresponsiveness to methacholine. Methacholine responsive
ness was expressed as a dose-response slope and ranks of dose-response
slopes were used in the analysis. Results - After accounting for impo
rtant confounding variables, there was no association between asthma a
nd salt intake, while methacholine dose-response slope ranks increased
with increasing salt intake and methacholine responsiveness was great
er in the highest quartile than in the lowest quartile of salt intake.
The median dose-response slopes in % fall in FEV(1) per mu mol methac
holine for quartiles I, II, III, and IV were 5.4, 5.9, 7.7, and 8.7. C
onclusions - No association was found between asthma or exercise-induc
ed bronchospasm and dietary salt intake. Bronchial hyperresponsiveness
to methacholine did, however, appear to increase with greater salt in
take, but the relevance of this association to asthma is unclear.