R. Warren et al., UNEXPECTEDLY HIGH-STRAIN DIVERSITY OF MYCOBACTERIUM-TUBERCULOSIS IN AHIGH-INCIDENCE COMMUNITY, South African medical journal, 86(1), 1996, pp. 45-49
Objective. To characterise Mycobacterium tuberculosis strains present
in a community experiencing an epidemic, in order to establish whether
a high rate of transmission results in low strain diversity. Design.
Sputum specimens collected for 18 months; IS6110-based DNA fingerprint
ing. Setting. The communities of Ravensmead and Uitsig, Cape Town, Sou
th Africa. Participants. Three hundred and thirty-four pulmonary tuber
culosis patients attending the Local Authority Health Care Clinic. Mai
n outcome measure. DNA fingerprinting. Results. A total of 334 M. tube
rculosis isolates were characterised by IS6110-based DNA fingerprintin
g; 209 strains were identified, 199 having 5 or more insertions. Forty
of these strains were present in 2 or more patients (clustering - 126
patients in total), which indicates a recent transmission rate of 30%
. The 163 unique strains suggest reactivation of latent infections. Co
mputer analysis showed a high degree of strain diversity, and a common
progenitor could only be linked to 33% of the strains. Clustering was
shown in 50% of drug-resistant isolates. Conclusions. The low rate of
transmission (30%) and the high degree of strain diversity (209 strai
ns) was unexpected and unexplained, given the high burden of disease i
n this community. The clustering of drug-resistant strains suggests th
at transmission, rather than lack of compliance, drives the spread of
antibiotic resistance in this community. Preliminary indications are t
hat BCG vaccination, while having little effect on the incidence of tu
berculosis in this community, may have altered the strain dynamics.