Rg. Lim et Pj. Carnevale, INFLUENCING MEDIATOR BEHAVIOR THROUGH BARGAINER FRAMING, The International journal of conflict management, 6(4), 1995, pp. 349-368
Research adopting prospect theory to examine negotiator performance wa
s extended to mediation. We examined whether framing negotiator payoff
s in terms of gains or losses affects a mediator's behavior towards ne
gotiators when the mediator has no personal frame. The use of a mediat
or presents a critical test between an explanation of framing effects
based on bargainers' underlying preferences for risk and a simpler exp
lanation based on the psychophysical properties of perceived gains and
losses. A computer-based experiment was conducted in which subjects a
cted as mediators between two disputants (computer programs) in an int
egrative bargaining task. As predicted subjects proposed settlements o
f higher joint value when both disputants had loss fr ames than when b
oth had gain frames, supporting the psychophysical explanation. Moreov
er, within mixed framed disputes, subjects' proposals favored the loss
-framed bargainer over the gain-framed bargainer. However, predicted i
nteractions between bargainer frame and concession-making activity wer
e not supported Implications of the results for real bargainers and me
diators are discussed.