We examined the mode of action of bisphosphonates on osteoclastic cell
recruitment using mouse marrow cultures with or without osteoblastic
cells. Tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase-positive multinucleated cel
ls [TRAP(+) MNC] formed in cultures were determined to be osteoclastic
cells. In marrow cultures, TRAP(+) MNC formation in the presence of 1
0(-8) mol/L 1,25(OH)(2)D-3 was not affected by the addition of 10(-6)
mol/L dihydrogen (cycloheptylamino)-methylenebisphosphonate monohydrat
e (YM175). However, it was inhibited in cocultures of marrow cells wit
h osteoblastic cells. The inhibitory effect was evident throughout the
entire culture period, YM175 dose dependently inhibited TRAP(+) MNC f
ormation, and other bisphosphonates-pamidronate and alendronate-also i
nhibited TRAP(+) MNC formation in the coculture. Similar observations
were also made in the coculture of spleen cells with osteoblastic cell
s. The conditioned media of osteoblastic cells treated with 10(-6) mol
/L, YM175 inhibited TRAP(+) MNC formation in marrow cultures. The pres
ence of YM175 in methylcellulose cultures affected neither the colony
formation of monocyte-macrophage lineage, nor TRAP(+) MNC formation in
the succeeding cocultures of recovered cells with osteoblastic cells.
These results indicate that YM175 and probably other bisphosphonates
as well preferentially inhibit the later stage of osteoclastogenesis t
hrough its action on osteoblastic cells. Our findings suggest that par
t of the inhibitory action by osteoblastic cells in the presence of bi
sphosphonates is mediated through soluble factor(s).