Gj. Retallack et al., GLOBAL COAL GAP BETWEEN PERMIAN-TRIASSIC EXTINCTION AND MIDDLE TRIASSIC RECOVERY OF PEAT-FORMING PLANTS, Geological Society of America bulletin, 108(2), 1996, pp. 195-207
Early Triassic coals are unknown, and Middle Triassic coals are rare a
nd thin. The Early Triassic coal gap began with extinction of peat for
ming plants at the end of the Permian (ca. 250 Ma), with no coal known
anywhere until Middle Triassic (243 Ma). Permian levels of plant dive
rsity and peat thickness were not recovered until Late Triassic (230 M
a). Tectonic and climatic explanations for the coal gap fail because d
eposits of fluctuating sea levels and sedimentary facies and paleosols
commonly found in coal-bearing sequences are present also in Early Tr
iassic rocks. Nor do we favor explanations involving evolutionary adva
nces in the effectiveness of fungal decomposers, insects or tetrapod h
erbivores, which became cosmopolitan and much reduced in diversity acr
oss the Permian-Triassic boundary, Instead, we favor explanations invo
lving extinction of peat-forming plants at the Permian-Triassic bounda
ry, followed by a hiatus of some 10 m.y. until newly evolved peat-form
ing plants developed tolerance to the acidic dysaerobic conditions of
wetlands. This view is compatible not only with the paleobotanical rec
ord of extinction of swamp plants, but also with indications of a term
inal Permian productivity crash from delta(13)C(org) and total organic
carbon of both nonmarine and shallow marine shales.