Gj. Tawa et al., SOLVATION FREE-ENERGY CALCULATIONS USING A CONTINUUM DIELECTRIC MODELFOR THE SOLVENT AND GRADIENT-CORRECTED DENSITY-FUNCTIONAL THEORY FOR THE SOLUTE, Journal of physical chemistry, 100(5), 1996, pp. 1515-1523
Electrostatic solvation free energies are calculated using a self cons
istent-reaction field(SCRF) procedure that combines a continuum dielec
tric model of the solvent with both Hartree-Fock (HF) and density func
tional theory (DFT) for the solute. Several molecules are studied in a
queous solution. They comprise three groups: nonpolar neutral, polar n
eutral, and ionic. The calculated values of Delta G(el) are sensitive
to the atomic radii used to define the solute molecular surface, parti
cularly to the value of the hydrogen radius. However, the values of De
lta G(el) exhibit reasonable correlation with experiment when a previo
usly determined, physically motivated set of atomic radii were used to
define the van der Waals surface of the solute. The standard deviatio
n between theory and experiment is 2.51 kcal/mol. for HF and 2.21 kcal
/mol for DFT for the 14 molecules examined. The errors with HF or DFT
are similar. The relative difference between the calculated values.of
Delta G(el) and experiment is largest for nonpolar neutral molecules,
intermediate for polar neutral molecules, and smallest for ions. This
is consistent with the expected relative importance of nonelectrostati
c contributions to the free energy that are omitted in the model.