Mathematical models of planktonic ecosystems use a variety of differen
t formulations to relate phytoplankton growth rates to environmental c
onditions. Does the formulation influence the model result? We have mo
dified the model of Fasham, Ducklow and McKelvie (J. Mar. Res., 34, 59
1-639, 1990) to test how its results would respond to changes in algal
growth rate formulations. The original model uses a Monod relationshi
p between nutrient concentration and relative growth rate, and a multi
plicative rule to combine light and nutrient effects. Use of a Droop f
ormulation for algal growth rate or a threshold (Blackman's law) mecha
nism to combine light and nutrient limitation produced significant cha
nges in simulation results. One important effect was to increase zoopl
ankton population and, as a result, the regenerated production. While
there are aesthetic reasons to prefer these alternate formulations, a
more accurate formulation will require more laboratory work on algal p
hysiology. Such laboratory work should be encouraged as an adjunct to
modeling work.