High-resolution X-ray scattering experiments have been performed on si
ngle crystals of Bi2Sr2CaCu2Oy grown independently by three different
research groups. Detailed measurements are presented of the X-ray scat
tering in the b-c* plane, paying particular attention to the weak dif
fuse features arranged around Bragg reflections in addition to the sat
ellites from the incommensurate modulation. The results clarify exactl
y which features are fundamental to the Bi2Sr2CaCu2Oy structure and wh
ich are due to sample-dependent effects. Features previously suggested
as indicating a primitive monoclinic symmetry are shown to be caused
by defects, thus confirming the generally accepted Bbmb space group. T
here are however, (in all crystals studied) extra diffuse peaks lying
on either side of the Bragg reflections which are unaccounted for by c
urrent structural models. These are shown to be characteristic of a lo
ss in ordering of the incommensurate modulation from layer to layer al
ong the c-axis.