J. Speed, BEHAVIORAL-MANAGEMENT OF CONVERSION DISORDER - RETROSPECTIVE STUDY, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation, 77(2), 1996, pp. 147-154
Objective: To assess whether operant behavioral treatment of conversio
n disorder provides effective and durable symptom resolution, and to e
valuate the prognostic value of duration of symptoms, as to the time r
equired to effect symptom resolution. Design: Retrospective case serie
s (consecutive sample). Setting: Inpatient rehabilitation unit in a te
rtiary care center. Patients: The first 10 patients with conversion di
sorder treated by the author. There were 5 men and 5 women, age range
19 to 69 years, mean 32.7 years. The duration of conversion disorder s
ymptoms (all involving gait) ranged from 0.5 to more than 112 weeks (m
ean 27.8 weeks, median 12 weeks). Follow-up range was 7 to 36 months (
mean 20 months). Intervention: All patients were treated as inpatients
using a behavioral approach. A 'pseudo-scientific' explanation of the
symptoms was provided, with an explanation that stressors can exacerb
ate symptoms. Patients were in a wheelchair when not in therapy, and a
physical therapy program was devised, using a treatment sequence base
d treatment of the analogous neurological condition. Other therapies w
ere also utilized for positive reinforcement of normal function. All p
atients had psychological cal evaluation, with treatment as indicated.
Patients were hospitalized long enough to restore normal gait and beg
in psychological treatment. Main Outcome Measures: Functional Independ
ence Measure ambulation score at admission, discharge, and follow-up,
and descriptive data, including symptom recurrence after discharge, ne
w neurological symptoms after discharge, new treatment since discharge
, and new psychiatric or neurological diagnosis since discharge. Resul
ts: All patients attained normal ambulation before discharge (n = 10,
Wilcoxon signed rank test p = .002). At followup, 7 of 9 patients main
tained normal ambulation (Wilcoxon signed rank test of pretreatment am
bulation score versus followup ambulation score p = .1016). Two patien
ts resumed partial dependence on wheelchair use. There was a Spearman
correlation coefficient of .68196 (p = .0298) when comparing duration
of symptoms against duration of treatment. No patient had symptom subs
titution or new diagnosis made during the follow up period. Conclusion
s: (1) Behavioral treatment of conversion disorder is effective, and a
ppears to provide a clinically (but not statistically) significant lon
g-lasting resolution of symptoms. (2) There is a strong positive corre
lation between duration of conversion symptoms and the time required t
o eradicate them. (C) 1996 by the American Congress of Rehabilitation
Medicine and the American Academy of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitat
ion.