A range of fungi was screened for the ability to suppress symptoms of
Dutch elm disease in European and hybrid elms under UK and Italian fie
ld conditions. The efficacy of the preventative inoculations varied co
nsiderably between elm clones of differing resistance to the causal fu
ngus Ophiostoma novo-ulmi. On susceptible English elm, Ulmus procera,
preventative inoculations with conidia of Verticillium dahliae, Ophios
toma ulmi or Ophiostoma piceae (OPH form) caused no reduction in final
disease levels. On U. x hollandica cv. 'Commelin', pretreatment with
V. dahliae or O. ulmi reduced final disease levels, but not significan
tly. On the elm clone Ca06 of U. carpinifolia, and on the hybrid clone
s FL025 and 196-6, significant (p < 0.05) symptom suppression occurred
in trees pretreated with O. ulmi or V. dahliae. On the more resistant
elm clones 3-14 and Lobel, only V. dahliae was an effective pretreatm
ent (p < 0.05). Certain pretreatment fungi alone caused symptoms in so
me of the elm clones. Major difficulties in using this approach to con
trol Dutch elm disease are discussed.