The effect of shock loads of long chain fatty acids (LCFA) on the acti
vity of granular methanogenic sludge was studied with capric acid as m
odel substrate. The results show that inhibition is primarily related
to the LCFA concentration; the LCFA:biomass ratio is less important. A
lethal threshold LCFA concentration can be distinguished in reactors
with identical physical and chemical conditions and inoculum propertie
s: the acetogenic and methanogenic population is killed virtually comp
letely when the concentration exceeds 6.7 to 9.0 mol/m3 capric acid. T
he observed variation in the threshold level may be attributable to di
fferences in mass transfer rate from liquid to granules in different e
xperiments. At most, 0.2% of the acetotrophic methanogens survives, wh
en the LCFA concentration in a methanogenic digester exceeds the letha
l threshold level. Mass balance analysis shows that obligate hydrogen
producing acetogenic bacteria and hydrogenotrophic methanogens recover
first, followed by acetotrophic methanogens. Recovery of acetotrophic
methanogenesis can be described by exponential growth of a small numb
er of survivors. Acetotrophic methanogens do not adapt to LCFA, neithe
r after repeated exposure to toxic concentrations, nor after prolonged
exposure to non-toxic concentrations.' A low LCFA (lipid) concentrati
on in the influent promotes faster growth of acetogenic bacteria capab
le of degrading LCFA.