The stereotype of the ''ecologically noble savage'' is still prevalent
in European-American discourses. I examine the empirical justificatio
ns offered for this stereotype, concluding that we lack sound empirica
l grounds for believing in ''ecological nobility.'' I argue that the s
tereotype should be abandoned because it has negative consequences for
native peoples. Instead of accepting questionable stereotypes, philos
ophers and others should focus on the lives of particular peoples in o
rder to understand their philosophies as well as the relationships tha
t they maintain with their homelands.