INTRACRYSTALLINE FRACTIONATION OF OXYGEN ISOTOPES BETWEEN HYDROXYL AND NON-HYDROXYL SITES IN KAOLINITE MEASURED BY THERMAL DEHYDROXYLATION AND PARTIAL FLUORINATION
Jp. Girard et Sm. Savin, INTRACRYSTALLINE FRACTIONATION OF OXYGEN ISOTOPES BETWEEN HYDROXYL AND NON-HYDROXYL SITES IN KAOLINITE MEASURED BY THERMAL DEHYDROXYLATION AND PARTIAL FLUORINATION, Geochimica et cosmochimica acta, 60(3), 1996, pp. 469-487
Thermal dehydroxylation and partial fluorination techniques were used
to measure intracrystalline fractionation of oxygen isotopes between h
ydroxyl and non-hydroxyl sites in kaolinite. Several aliquots of a wel
l characterized, fine-grained (<1 mu m) kaolinite from Macon, GA, were
dehydroxylated in vacuo using a variety of heating procedures, heatin
g rates, and target temperatures. Measured delta(18)O values of both t
he liberated water and the dehydroxylated residue are consistent over
a wide range of temperatures (550-850 degrees C) when dehydroxylation
is performed in a single-step fashion at a rapid heating rate (>50 deg
rees C/min.). Similar dehydroxylation experiments indicate that brucit
e dehydroxylation occurs without any significant isotopic fractionatio
n of the oxygen isotopes. By extrapolation we postulate that no signif
icant fractionation occurs during single-step thermal dehydroxylation
of fine-grained kaolinite, provided that dehydroxylation is performed
under well controlled conditions. In contrast, gibbsite dehydroxylatio
n is accompanied by substantial isotopic fractionation. This is probab
ly the result of the complex, multi-pathway dehydroxylation reaction o
f this mineral. Similarly, thermal dehydroxylation of coarse-grained (
>1 mu m) kaolinites and dickites of weathering and hydrothermal origin
yield results that are dependent on the temperature of dehydroxylatio
n. We suggest that this effect may be caused by isotopic exchange duri
ng diffusion of water molecules through coarse particles. Partial fluo
rination of fine-grained kaolinite in the presence of excess F-2 at lo
w temperatures (<185 degrees C) yields unreproducible delta(18)O value
s. When performed at high temperatures (220-240 degrees C) in the pres
ence of insufficient F-2, delta(18)O values are systematically lower t
han the bulk delta(18)O value and increase linearly with the percent s
toichiometric yield. They are consistent with a greater rate of reacti
on of hydroxyl oxygen than of non-hydroxyl oxygen, but examination of
the isotopic data as well as XRD and IR analyses of the residues after
partial fluorination indicates that the separation between the two ty
pes of oxygen is not complete. The results, therefore, do not yield a
reliable delta(18)O value of the hydroxyl oxygen. The results of this
study suggest that the thermal dehydroxylation technique may be approp
riate for analysis of OH groups in fine-grained kaolinite. The partial
fluorination approach appears less suitable. Intracrystalline fractio
nation of oxygen isotopes between hydroxyl and non-hydroxyl sites in k
aolinite may be larger than previously reported in experimental studie
s. Based on the results obtained for the finer-than 1 mu m Macon kaoli
nite a value of 1.0272 is proposed for the intracrystalline fractionat
ion factor, alpha(non-OH/OH), Of kaolinite at 20 +/- 10 degrees C.