M. Helm et al., SEMIQUANTITATIVE CAPNOMETRY - USEFUL IN T HE VERIFICATION OF ENDOTRACHEAL-TUBE PLACEMENT IN TRAUMA PATIENTS, Der Unfallchirurg, 99(1), 1996, pp. 11-16
Severely injured patients, in particular, benefit from initiation of e
ndotracheal intubation and controlled ventilation before hospital admi
ssion. The most frequent and most serious mishap of this emergency pro
cedure is inadvertent esophageal tube placement. A reliable and simple
determination of proper tube placement involves capnometry, the measu
rement of carbon dioxide concentration during the respiratory cycle. T
he purpose of this study was to evaluate the dependability of semi-qua
ntitative capnometry in verifying proper tube placement in the prehosp
ital treatment of trauma patients. First, we determined and tested the
suitability of the equipment used in this study (STAT CAP) in 40 pati
ents under controlled hospital conditions; subsequently, we tested it
under prehospital conditions on 40 trauma patients. Within the two stu
dy groups, the STAT CAP proved to be of high sensitivity (1.0) and spe
cificity (1.0) in identifying tracheal tube position immediately after
intubation manoeuvre, even in patients with a shock index >1 (n = 14)
and patients with cardiac arrest (n = 3). In cases of tracheal tube p
osition, a CO2 signal was noted after two ventilations, on average, in
both study groups. The average initial CO2 value recorded amongst the
hospital study group was 30-50 mmHg, against 20-30 mmHg in the prehos
pital trauma group. The traditional signs used to verify endotracheal
tube placement (direct visualization of the cords and auscultation of
sounds upon the chest) failed in three cases amongst the prehospital t
rauma group; in all of these cases the STAT CAP detected the (tracheal
) tube placement correctly. We conclude that the STAT CAP reliably det
ects tracheal placement of endotracheal tube in non-arrested patients.
In the arrested patient, interpretation of CO2 nonappearance requires
caution. In addition to the traditional clinical signs, semi-quantita
tive capnometry is a meaningful supplement to verify tracheal tube pla
cement in the prehospital management of trauma patients.