Wm. Murphy et al., REACTION-KINETICS AND THERMODYNAMICS OF AQUEOUS DISSOLUTION AND GROWTH OF ANALCIME AND NA-CLINOPTILOLITE AT 25-DEGREES-C, American journal of science, 296(2), 1996, pp. 128-186
Low-temperature (25 degrees C), long-term (up to 2.6 yr) batch-type di
ssolution and precipitation experiments have been conducted to examine
reaction kinetics and thermodynamics of aqueous dissolution and growt
h of analcime and Na-clinoptilolite at pH close to 9. Experimental dat
a show that analcime dissolution and growth are approximately stoichio
metric. Mass transfer data indicate that no other solid phases influen
ced analcime dissolution and growth experiments at aqueous SiO2 concen
trations less than approx 4 ppm. Dissolution rate data for analcime ca
nnot be rationalized using a fixed preaffinity rate constant. Two hypo
thetical dissolution mechanisms provide reasonable interpretations of
the mass transfer rate data. One hypothesis invokes the presence of a
mass of surface material that reacts rapidly and dissolves completely.
The bulk material is hypothesized to react in parallel with the extra
-reactive material according to a smaller rate constant. In an alterna
te hypothesis also yielding a good data regression, the reaction rate
is assumed to be inversely proportional to the square of the aqueous A
I(OH)4 activity as well as reaction affinity. existing data do not per
mit a selection among these or other possible mechanisms, the decrease
in reaction rate with reaction progress under conditions that are far
from equilibrium offers a likely explanation for reported discrepanci
es between laboratory and field weathering rate measurements. The equi
librium solubility of analcime was closely approached from both unders
aturation and supersaturation. Interpretation of the aqueous solution
data permits extraction of the equilibrium constant and standard state
Gibbs free energy for the analcime dissolution reaction and the stand
ard state Gibbs free energy of formation of analcime. The equilibrium
solubility of analcime obtained in this study differs significantly fr
om values based on thermodynamic data reported in the literature. Rele
ase of Si in Na-clinoptilolite dissolution studies follows a systemati
c pattern of decreasing rate with increasing solution concentration an
d approach to equilibrium. The time-dependent data can be rationalized
using a conventional dissolution rate equation. Net release of Al is
much less than that of Si, indicating incongruent dissolution. Attempt
s to determine the solubility of Na-clinoptilolite were complicated I
precipitation of an unidentified, low-solubility, aluminous JY phase.
Nevertheless, a provisional equilibrium constant and corresponding sta
ndard Gibbs free energy for the dissolution reaction and standard stat
e Gibbs free energy of formation of Na-clinoptilolite were extracted f
rom the data, adopting plausible assumptions about the composition of
the equilibrated clinoptilolite and the saturation state of the experi
mental solutions. Groundwater chemical data from the tuffaceous aquife
r in the vicinity of Yucca Mountain and from Oasis Valley, Nevada, hav
e aqueous silica activities that vary over a small range at a value gr
eater than that corresponding to mutual equilibration of analcime and
Na-clinoptilolite. Reported chemical analyses including data for aqueo
us aluminum indicate that the natural waters appear to be at equilibri
um with analcime using thermodynamic data derived in this study. Howev
er the natural waters are supersaturated with respect to the provision
al Na-clinoptilolite solubility.