J. Haydock et al., EXTRA-PAIR PATERNITY UNCOMMON IN THE COOPERATIVELY BREEDING BICOLOREDWREN, Behavioral ecology and sociobiology, 38(1), 1996, pp. 1-16
We investigated parentage using multilocus DNA fingerprinting for 222
juveniles produced during 99 group-years in the bicolored wren Campylo
rhynchus griseus, a cooperatively breeding bird of the Venezuelan sava
nna. Young adult bicolored wrens (auxiliaries) remain in their natal t
erritories and substantially enhance the production of young there. We
have previously used behavioral indicators of dominance by a single m
ale/female pair (principals) to infer breeding status, resulting in th
e commonly applied model of helping in which current fitness accrues t
o auxiliaries only indirectly, in proportion to their relatedness to t
he principals and the effect of their assistance on breeding success.
Our parentage analysis has demonstrated that 8.6% of the juveniles fou
nd on territories were not produced by the principal pair. Parentage o
f 4.1% of the juveniles was completely outside the social group; these
appear to result from early dispersal of juveniles rather than from b
rood parasitism, most likely resulting from breakup of nearby groups.
Principal females mated outside of their group (2.3%), or with an auxi
liary male (2.3%), in the remaining cases of parentage outside the pri
ncipal pair. No matings were detected between close relatives (e.g. mo
ther-son); matings detected between the principal female and an auxili
ary male followed a typical replacement of the principal female by an
unrelated immigrant female. Our fingerprinting results indicate that:
(1) current fitness benefits accruing to most auxiliaries do not excee
d their likely reproductive success had they dispersed successfully to
a breeding position; (2) nearly all wren mating is monogamous and (3)
behavioral dominants (especially females) can monopolize breeding.