Cr. Ross et al., STRUCTURE AND CRYSTAL-FIELD SPECTRA OF CO3AL2(SIO4)(3) AND (MG,NI)(3)AL-2(SIO4)(3) GARNET, The American mineralogist, 81(1-2), 1996, pp. 61-66
Synthetic Co3Al2(SiO4)(3) garnet and (Mg,Ni)(3)Al-2(SiO4)(3) garnet wi
th Ni/(Ni + Mg) = 0.15-0.18 have been studied by single-crystal X-ray
diffraction and optical spectroscopy. The X-ray data confirm that Co2 and Ni2+ occupy the large distorted cubic (dodecahedral) site of the
structure. Structure refinement indicates that the Ni2+ ion is probabl
y displaced out of the center of this site and statically or dynamical
ly disordered onto the 48g equipoint at (1/8,y,1/4+y). This is consist
ent with the lattice constant of the Ni-bearing garnet of 11.4717(7) A
ngstrom being significantly larger than the lattice constant of pyrope
(11.459 Angstrom), although the ionic radius of Ni2+ is usually small
er than that of Mg2+. The lattice constant of Co3Al2(SiO4)(3) garnet i
s 11.4597(2) Angstrom. Because of the unusual coordination geometries
of Ni2+ and Co2+, the optical spectra of the garnets are fundamentally
different from those of other Co2+- and Ni2+-bearing silicates. The f
ollowing crystal-field parameters were estimated from spectroscopic da
ta: crystal-field splitting Delta = 4430 cm(-1) (Co2+) and 4210 cm(-1)
(Ni2+); Racah parameter B = 890 cm(-1) (Co2+) and 1080 cm(-1) (Ni2+).
These data yield an exceptionally low crystal-field stabilization ene
rgy (CFSE) of Ni2+ in garnet of 3370 cm(-1), which explains the very l
ow Ni contents of garnets in equilibrium with olivine. The CFSE of Co2
+ in garnet of 5320 cm(-1) is similar to values for pyroxenes and oliv
ine. Therefore, the partition coefficient of Co2+ between these phases
should be close to unity, as is observed.