Ew. Randall et al., FERTILIZATION EFFECTS ON ORGANIC-MATTER IN PHYSICALLY FRACTIONATED SOILS AS STUDIED BY C-13 NMR - RESULTS FROM 2 LONG-TERM FIELD EXPERIMENTS, European journal of soil science, 46(4), 1995, pp. 557-565
C-13-nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectra taken using magic-angle
spinning (MAS), cross polarization (CP) and with total suppression of
side bands (TOSS) are reported for soils from two long-term field expe
riments. One set of soils was from the Broadbalk Experiment at Rothams
ted, UK (monoculture of winter wheat since 1843) and the other was fro
m the Lermarken site of the Askov Long-Term Experiment on Animal Manur
e and Mineral Fertilizers (arable rotation since 1894). At both sites
soil samples were taken from three fertilizer treatments: nil, inorgan
ic fertilizers, animal manure. Spectra were obtained from whole soil s
amples and from the size fractions clay (<2 mu m), silt (2-20 mu m) an
d, in some cases, sand (20-2000 mu m). Comparison of the total strengt
hs of the C-13-NMR signal for each size separate in relation to its to
tal organic C content shows that clay, particularly, contains large pe
rcentages of C not detected by NMR because of the large magnetic susce
ptibilities of the soil minerals. It is proposed that the bi observed
signals come from the more labile pools of soil organic matter (SOM),
on the presumption that these pools are less closely associated with s
oil minerals and iron oxides and are likely to be less protected from
microbial or enzymic decomposition. For both Rothamsted and Askov, fun
ctional groups in the 45-110 ppm region (N- and O-alkyls) dominate in
the spectra for whole soils, with aromatics (110-160 ppm) and alkyls (
0-45 ppm) signals being the next prominent. In the Askov whole soil sa
mples C-13-NMR revealed no differences between nil, inorganic fertiliz
er and animal manure treatments but in the Rothamsted whole soil there
were some small differences. Clay and silt fractions from Askov conta
in more alkyls and less aromatics than those from Rothamsted. For both
sites clay in enriched in alkyls and depleted in aromatics relative t
o silt. Clay from Askov, but not Rothamsted, contains more N-alkyls (4
5-65 ppm) and less acetals (90-110 ppm) than silt. O-alkyls (65-90 ppm
) account for more than 20% of the total signal in clay and silt from
both sites. Fertilization regimes have not significantly affected the
chemical composition of SOM associated with clay- and silt-sized fract
ions in the soils at either site. We conclude that the chemical compos
ition of SOM is determined primarily by the interaction between the or
ganisms responsible for decomposition and the mineral soil matrix rath
er than the nature of substrate input.