Saturated soil culture (SSC), where crops are grown in soil continuous
ly irrigated to maintain a high moisture content, has resulted in larg
e increases in soybean seed yield. Common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.)
is considered sensitive to flooding and has a shorter growth cycle th
an soybean. Thus, it was anticipated that an evaluation of response of
common bean to SSC might provide an instructive contrast. Four field
trials were conducted at Palmira, Colombia to evaluate the response of
different bean lines to SSC which resulted in up to 20% yield increas
e. However, effectiveness of SSC varied with trial and bean line. In a
comparison of ten lines previously characterized for adaptation to wa
ter deficit, nine lines suggested a strong negative association betwee
n relative yields under SSC and yield under water deficit (r = -0.84,
P < 0.01) and relative yield under SSC and root length density under w
ater deficit (r = -0.79, P < 0.01). The tenth showed high yields under
both SSC and water deficit. Physiological maturity was delayed by SSC
, and canopy dry weight increased while seed yield was improved. Effec
ts on harvest index were variable with trial and line. Mean leaf condu
ctance was higher and leaf temperature lower in SSC, suggesting that S
SC improves crop water status. Although positive effects on seed yield
were detected, response to SSC was less favorable than reported for s
oybean.