A. Mcintosh, THE EMPEROR HAS NO CLOTHES - LET US PAINT OUR LOINCLOTHS RAINBOW - A CLASSICAL AND FEMINIST CRITIQUE OF CONTEMPORARY SCIENCE POLICY, Environmental values, 5(1), 1996, pp. 3-30
The British government's White Paper on science together with governme
nt research council reports are used as a basis for critiquing current
science policy and its intensifying orientation, British and worldwid
e, towards industrial and military development. The critique draws par
ticulary on Plate and Bacon as yardsticks to address who science is fo
r, what values it honours and where current policy departs from impera
tives of socio-ecological justice. Metaphors of the 'Emperor's new clo
thes' and incremental spectral shift in attitude help illuminate both
the problems and ways forward. The paper calls for a re-integration of
classical perspectives with added insights, often ecofeminist, from p
hilosophy, poetics and a theology of reverence. Predication on the val
ues of love, interconnectedness and orientation towards childrens' all
-round development should be central to curricular reform. Consistent
with the views of Plate, the original founder of the Academy, the util
itarian role of science ought to be balanced with a contemplative role
of science as the art of knowing ourselves in relation to nature. Onl
y with such a holistic academic approach can it adequately rise to pro
viding a pedagogy of authentic human development, service to the poor
and remedies, rather than contribution, to the ongoing destruction of
nature.