This paper investigates whether choice of health insurance is influenc
ed by the perceived mental and physical health of family members among
a sample of policy-holders with private health insurance. A multinomi
al probit model of the choice among major medical coverage only, tradi
tional full coverage, and coverage through a health maintenance organi
zation is estimated. Results indicate that the presence of at least on
e family member who rates his or her general health as poor does not a
ffect the policy-holder's choice of health insurance. However, the pre
sence of at least one family member considered at risk of mental illne
ss does in some instances affect the policy-holder's choice of health
insurance: We observe significant effects for policy-holders who are f
emale, black, have some college education, work for a large firm, and
live in an urban area. These findings suggest that adverse selection m
ay arise when individuals are able to choose between health insurance
policies with different degrees of coverage for mental health care and
that such effects are far more pronounced for those people who consid
er themselves at risk for mental illness than physical illness.