Let p be a prime or 0. A presentation P (defining a group G) is said t
o be p-Cockcroft if the map pi(2)(P) --> H-2(P, Z(p)) is 0 (where Z(0)
= Z). Moreover, if H is a subgroup of G then P is pH-Cockcroft if the
covering of P (regarded as a 2-complex) corresponding to H is p-Cockc
roft. These concepts, and other Cockcroft notions, are related to the
minimality and efficiency of presentations, and to the ''relation gap'
' problem (in particular, a finite presentation is efficient if and on
ly if it is p-Cockcroft for some prime p). If P is p-Cockcroft then th
ere exist minimal subgroups H of G for which P is pH-Cockcroft, called
p-Cockcroft thresholds (these were introduced by Harlander and Gilber
t - Howie when p = 0). We investigate these thresholds. Finally, we ob
tain necessary and sufficient conditions for the ''natural'' presentat
ions for various group constructions ((generalized) graphs of groups,
split extensions, direct products) to be p-Cockcroft. In particular, w
e see why it is difficult to find minimal presentations for direct pro
ducts.