Background & Aims: Patients with hereditary nonpolyposis colorectal ca
ncer (HNPCC) have been suggested to have a better prognosis than patie
nts with common sporadic colorectal cancer. However, the evidence has
not been convincing. The aim of this population-based study was to com
pare the survival rates of 175 patients with HNPCC with those of 14,00
0 patients with sporadic colorectal cancer diagnosed at <65 years of a
ge in Finland from 1953 to 1993, Methods: The recent progress in molec
ular genetics of hereditary colorectal cancer was utilized for the fir
st time. One hundred twenty of the patients with HNPCC came from famil
ies segregating a germline mutation in the MLH1 cancer predisposition
gene. Results: The overall 5-year cumulative relative survival rate wa
s 65% for patients with HNPCC and 44% for patients with sporadic color
ectal cancer. The relative survival rates of patients with HNPCC were
better in every strata analyzed. Conclusions: MLH1-associated colorect
al cancer has a natural history different from that of common sporadic
colorectal cancer. The better survival rates may be caused by the hea
vy mutation burden affecting mismatch repair deficient tumor cells.