An open, randomized, prospective study was carried out to compare the
clinical efficacy and safety of phenoxymethylpenicillin with that of m
inocycline in the treatment of erythema migrans. Sixty patients (minoc
ycline 30, penicillin 30) were enrolled in the study. The two groups o
f patients were statistically homogeneous regarding age and sex distri
bution. IgG and IgM antibodies against Borrelia burgdorferi were deter
mined by ELISA before and after treatment and 1 year thereafter. Thirt
y-nine patients completed the study. All these patients (penicillin 21
, minocycline 18) who received a 21-day course of treatment were free
of clinical symptoms of late Lyme borreliosis after 1 year. Serum anti
bodies against B. burgdorferi could be detected before treatment in 6/
21 patients treated with penicillin and 3/18 patients treated with min
ocycline. After 1 year 8/39 patients were seropositive without any evi
dence of ongoing disease. In the remaining 21 patients treatment could
not be completed with the initial antibiotic due to side effects (pen
icillin 9/30, minocycline 12/30). One patient, who stopped penicillin
treatment at day 14 and one patient who stopped minocycline at day 4,
developed fatigue and memory impairment within the observation period.
A 3-week course of treatment with penicillin or minocycline is equall
y effective in treating patients with erythema migrans and preventing
late symptoms of Lyme borreliosis.