Hypercapnia produces an uncomfortable urge to breathe ('air hunger'),
which is alleviated by increasing breathing. It has been postulated th
at awake humans control breathing partly to minimize these sensations;
such behavioral control presumably involves the forebrain. To test th
is postulate, we compared the ventilatory response to hypercapnia when
the subject breathed spontaneously to the response when the subject u
sed forebrain commands to control ventilation-on the basis of minimizi
ng air hunger (achieved with subject-controlled positive pressure vent
ilation). In six healthy adults during hypercapnia (46 mmHg), spontane
ous ventilation significantly exceeded, by 17%, the level of (mechanic
al) ventilation needed to alleviate air hunger. This suggests that spo
ntaneous breathing is not behaviorally controlled to minimize discomfo
rt. Alternatively, mechanical ventilation confers an additional relief
of air hunger beyond that provided by spontaneous breathing. Since me
chanical ventilation (with reduced respiratory muscle contraction) was
more effective than spontaneous breathing in relieving air hunger, ou
r results also suggest afferents that signal the degree of respiratory
muscle contraction do not contribute to air hunger relief.