Limiting dilution (LD) cultures are often used to study cellular heter
ogeneity in responses of murine splenocytes to specific or polyclonal
activation. LD titration curves often reveal a nonlinear dependence of
response on input cell dose. Although 'zigzag' shaped curves of this
kind are often interpreted and analyzed as resulting from interactions
among three distinct cell types, we observe that a more parsimonious
two cell model, including a cell type that can generate both positive
and negative effects, provides better fit to a wide range of experimen
tal data. We have developed mathematical models for the accurate estim
ation of the frequencies of both interacting cell types and of the par
ameters for their multi-hit interaction. We show examples of LD cultur
es in which specific experimental manipulations alter the frequency of
only one of the two cell types, or alter the interaction parameters w
ithout a change in responder frequency. We also provide a simplified m
ethod for approximation of the model parameters using graphical approa
ches and simple algebra. Lastly, we present an improved method for cal
culation of the effect generated per responder cell in microclonal cul
tures.