Wm. Tierney et al., USING ELECTRONIC MEDICAL RECORDS TO PREDICT MORTALITY IN PRIMARY-CAREPATIENTS WITH HEART-DISEASE - PROGNOSTIC POWER AND PATHOPHYSIOLOGIC IMPLICATIONS, Journal of general internal medicine, 11(2), 1996, pp. 83-91
OBJECTIVE: To identify high-risk patients with heart disease by using
data stored in an electronic medical record system to predict six-year
mortality. DESIGN: Retrospective cohort study. SETTING: Academic prim
ary care general internal medicine practice affiliated with an urban t
eaching hospital with a state-of-the-art electronic medical record sys
tem. PATIENTS: Of 2,434 patients with evidence of ischemic heart disea
se or heart failure or both who visited an urban primary care practice
in 1986, half were used to derive a proportional hazards model, and h
alf were used to validate it.MEASUREMENTS: Mortality from any cause wi
thin six years of inception date. Model discrimination was assessed wi
th the C statistic, and goodness-of-fit was measured with a calibratio
n curve and Hosmer-Lemeshow statistic. MAIN RESULTS: Of these patients
82% had evidence of ischemic heart disease, 53% heart failure, and 35
% both conditions. Mean survival among the 653 (27%) who died was 2.8
years; mean follow-up among survivors was 5.0 years. Those with both h
eart conditions had the highest mortality rate (45% at 6 years), follo
wed by isolated heart failure (39%) and ischemic heart disease (18%).
Of 300 potential predictive characteristics, 100 passed a univariate s
creen and were submitted to multivariable proportional hazards regress
ion. Twelve variables contributed independent predictive information:
age, weight, more than one previous hospitalization for heart failure,
and nine conditions indicated on diagnostic tests and problem lists.
No drug treatment variables were independent predictors. The model C s
tatistic was 0.76 in the derivation sample of patients and 0.74 in a r
andomly selected validation sample, and it was well calibrated. Patien
ts in the lowest and highest quartiles of risk differed more than five
-fold in their average risk. CONCLUSIONS: Routine clinical data stored
in patients' electronic medical records are capable of predicting mor
tality among patients with heart disease. This could allow increasingl
y scarce health care resources to be focused on those at highest morta
lity risk.