LEAD AND SULFUR ISOTOPE INVESTIGATION OF PALEOZOIC SEDIMENTARY-ROCKS FROM THE SOUTHERN MIDCONTINENT OF THE UNITED-STATES - IMPLICATIONS FORPALEOHYDROLOGY AND ORE GENESIS OF THE SOUTHEAST MISSOURI LEAD BELTS
Mb. Goldhaber et al., LEAD AND SULFUR ISOTOPE INVESTIGATION OF PALEOZOIC SEDIMENTARY-ROCKS FROM THE SOUTHERN MIDCONTINENT OF THE UNITED-STATES - IMPLICATIONS FORPALEOHYDROLOGY AND ORE GENESIS OF THE SOUTHEAST MISSOURI LEAD BELTS, Economic geology and the bulletin of the Society of Economic Geologists, 90(7), 1995, pp. 1875-1910
This study utilizes Pb isotope data to identify flow paths and Pb sour
ces for Mississippi Valley-type ores in the midcontinent of the United
States with emphasis on the Old and Nerv Lead Belt subdistricts bf so
utheast Missouri. Nearly 150 new analyses are reported which character
ize the,isotope systematics of both ore samples and Pb hosted by sedim
entary rocks away from ore districts. A subset of the samples has been
analyzed for sulfur isotopes. The nonore samples contain trace amount
s of Pb largely hosted by trace metal-rich FeS2 (termed ''sulfide trac
e Pb''). These metal-rich sulfide phases are constrained by previous p
etrographic studies to have precipitated from the mineralizing fluids
responsible for Mississippi Valley-type ore formation. Sampling was de
signed to evaluate the role of potential Cambrian and Ordovician aquif
ers as transport paths for Pb and S in an area broadly surrounding the
locus of lead belt mineralization in southeast Missouri. Analyses are
also presented for various leach fractions of rocks (termed ''rock Pb
'') associated with these same potential aquifer units. Analyses of or
e samples establish important benchmarks with which to compare the non
ore samples. Ore samples were analyzed from southeast Missouri and inc
lude new data for both galena and nongalena phases (chalcopyrite, spha
lerite, dolomite) from the New Lead belt subdistrict (Viburnum Trend s
ubdistrict), and galena from the Old Lead Belt subdistrict and the out
lying subdistricts of Annapolis and Indian Creek. Also studied were ga
lena samples from the Central Missouri and Tri-State districts. The ne
w data plus published values from the Northern Arkansas and Upper Miss
issippi Valley districts are nearly collinear on a uranogenic Pb isoto
pe plot (Pb-206/Pb-204 vs. Pb-207/Pb-204). The slope of the linear reg
ression line through this data is consistent with all the ores having
been derived from the approximately 1450 Ma basement in the midcontine
nt area. However, the ores are very clearly separated on a plot of tho
rogenic isotope data (Pb-206/Pb-204 vs. Pb-208/Pb-204). Ores from eith
er end of the Illinois basin, the Upper Mississippi Valley and Illinoi
s-Kentucky fluorspar districts, have markedly higher Pb-208/Pb-204 for
a given Pb-206/Pb-204 compared to ores from the ore districts in the
Ozark region. Conversely, data from main-stage galena samples from the
Viburnum Trend (which are commonly cube octahedral in morphology but
which may also be disseminated in the host rock) and limited data from
the Old Lead Belt are notable for having a lower Pb-208/Pb-204 for a
given Pb-206/Pb-204 compared not only to Illinois basin-associated ore
s but also compared to data from other districts in the Ozark region a
nd even to paragenetically later, and volumetrically minor, cubic-stag
e mineralization data from the Viburnum Trend itself. Identifying the
transport path and source for the Pb-208-depleted main-stage ores of t
he lead belts was a major goal of this study. Uranogenic Pb isotope da
ta for sulfide trace Pb samples are generally collinear with ore Pb da
ta. This similarity indicates that a basement source is also possible
for sulfide trace Pb; however,the thorogenic isotopic plot shows much
more complexity. Pb isotope data from samples of dominantly dolomitic
Cambrian and Ordovician units younger than the Upper Cambrian Bonneter
re Formation form an array which is collinear with data from the North
ern Arkansas, Tri State, and Central Missouri districts and with the m
ost radiogenic values from the late-stage cubic mineralization. This a
rray is Significantly enriched in Pb-208 compared to main-stage Viburn
um Trend mineralization. Data from the Bonneterre Formation, which hos
ts ore in the lead belts, show more scatter but tend to show even more
Pb-208 enrichment compared to main-stage lead belt data. This trend t
oward increased scatter and increased Pb-208 enrichment continues to b
e supported by isotopic data from the underlying, coarse elastic Lamot
te Sandstone, which many have postulated as a major aquifer for ore ge
nesis in southeast Missouri. Thus, an extensive data set from a large
area surrounding the lead belts failed to identify the isotopic tracks
of Pb-208-depleted main-stage lend belt mineralization in aquifer uni
ts hosting sulfide-associated Pb, but did identify potential aquifers
associated with dolomitic, post-Bonne-terre Cambrian rocks for Pb tran
sport to less Pb-rich Mississippi Valley-type districts such as Tri-St
ate, Northern Arkansas, and Central Missouri. The sulfide trace Pb sam
ples present data which show that they are systematically enriched in
S-32 (i.e., delta(34)S < 10%) compared to samples of main-stage ores o
f the Viburnum Trend (delta(34)S > 10 parts per thousand), although is
otopically heavy trace sulfides are localized in the upper Bonneterre
Formation. Combined Pb and S isotope data for sulfide trace Pb samples
do not reflect the signature expected of a single, unique Mississippi
Valley-type ore-forming fluid for the lead belts but are indicative o
f a fluid which could have represented the isotopically light S and sl
ightly Pb-208-enriched end member of a mixture. Pb isotope data from l
eaches of rock samples from the Bonneterre Formation (a predominantly
carbonate unit) and the elastic Lamotte Sandstone are easily distingui
shable. On a thorogenic isotope plot, the Bonneterre Formation results
, from both limestones and dolomites, form a linear array that is in g
ood agreement with the array formed by sulfide trace Pb samples hosted
by carbonate rock units (i.e., exclusive of the Lamotte Sandstone). T
he combined Pb isotope array, which we term the ''midcontinent carbona
te Pb line'' is interpreted to reflect both sources of Pb (primary lim
estone and premineralization dolomite) and sinks (trace Pb,in sulfides
and ore-stage hydrothermal dolomite). The slope of the uranogenic plo
t for the midcontinent carbonate Pb line, which gives an age similar t
o that of both ores and basement rocks, is interpreted to indicate an
ultimate basement source for the uranium in these units, but some pref
erential transport and incorporation of U over Th did occur during for
mation of these rocks. A major finding of this study is that thorogeni
c Pb isotope data on sock Pb from the Lamotte Sandstone (supported by
published data on Pb trapped in presumed ore-stage authigenic K feldsp
ar) yield the Pb-208-depleted isotope signature expected for rocks of
a transport path of main-stage Pb. The marked contrast betwe