We conducted a survey to identify for the US Environmental Protection
Agency examples of and reasons for the failure of many previously inst
alled methane recovery systems. Six dairy producers participated in th
is survey. Installation costs of systems ranged from $100,000 to $950,
000. Three producers have continued their dairy operations but no long
er use methane recovery technology. Two producers were favorable to th
e technology but no longer operate a dairy. Of those surveyed, only on
e producer continues to use methane recovery technology. Identified pr
oblems associated with unsuccessful operations included poor design, c
ollection of manure in a wet form, and incomplete cooperation from ele
ctric companies. Producers found that the technology required intense
management and was economically risky. Increased cooperation between e
lectric companies and small producers of electricity and greater price
s paid for electricity might provide positive economic incentives that
would encourage methane recovery and electricity generation. One prod
ucer indicated that the benefits from anaerobic digester technology to
be emphasized to potential users were income from sales of final soli
ds and the nutrient value of both solid and liquid effluent streams as
fertilizer sources.