The objectives of the present study were (1) to ascertain the lifetime
risk of a depression in a representative group of multiple sclerosis
(MS) patients, (2) to assess the morbidity risks for depression among
first-degree relatives of these MS patients, and (3) to compare these
familial risks for first-degree relatives of MS patients with those fo
r first-degree relatives of a primary depression population, i.e., dep
ression but no MS. We psychiatrically evaluated 221 MS patients (index
cases) using a structured clinical interview for the DSM-III-P and ca
lculated the rate and lifetime risk of depression for these index case
s using the product limit estimate of survival function. We obtained p
sychiatric histories for all first-degree relatives of index cases, an
d we calculated morbidity risks for depression for these relatives usi
ng the maximum likelihood approach and compared the risks using the li
kelihood ratio tests. Index cases had a 50.3% lifetime risk of a depre
ssion. Morbidity risks for depression among first-degree relatives of
index cases were decidedly lower when compared with morbidity risks am
ong first-degree relatives of the reference population. Although there
appears to be a very high rate of depression among MS patients, the d
ata for their first-degree relatives do not support a clear genetic ba
sis for this depression, or at least the same genetic basis that proba
bly operates within families when depression occurs in the absence of
MS.