R. Torronen et al., SERUM BETA-CAROTENE RESPONSE TO SUPPLEMENTATION WITH RAW CARROTS, CARROT JUICE OR PURIFIED BETA-CAROTENE IN HEALTHY NONSMOKING WOMEN, Nutrition research, 16(4), 1996, pp. 565-575
Epidemiological studies have shown that high intake of carotenoid-rich
vegetables and fruits and high blood levels of beta-carotene are asso
ciated with decreased risk of cancer. In western countries, carrot is
the most important source of dietary beta-carotene. In the present stu
dy, the serum response to chronic ingestion of beta-carotene from raw
carrots, carrot juice and capsules containing purified beta-carotene w
as studied. The subjects were 38 healthy, non-smoking female volunteer
s, aged 20-53 years. They were instructed to consume low-carotenoid di
ets for 10 days before starting the supplementation and throughout the
study. According to food frequency questionnaires, the average habitu
al intake of beta-carotene was 4.5 mg/day, whereas the low-carotenoid
diet provided only 0.4 mg/day. After the 10-day depletion period, the
average serum beta-carotene concentration fell to 53 % of the habitual
level. The participants were assigned into three groups with similar
mean serum beta-carotene concentrations. Each group was supplemented f
or 6 weeks with approximately 12 mg of beta-carotene/day, either as ra
w carrots (120 g/day), carrot juice (1 dl/day) or beta-carotene capsul
es (2 capsules/day). The increase in serum beta-carotene level was det
ermined after 3 and 6 weeks of supplementation. The mean serum beta-ca
rotene concentration increased significantly in all test groups, the r
esponse being greatest in the group receiving beta-carotene capsules.
No difference in the serum response between carrot and carrot juice wa
s detected. However, there was a wide variation in the individual resp
onse of serum beta-carotene to supplementation, regardless of the sour
ce. Variation was especially large - ranging from a lack of response t
o over 8-fold increase in the serum beta-carotene concentration - in t
he group receiving beta-carotene capsules. These data indicate that 1)
serum response is lower after ingestion of natural beta-carotene than
after ingestion of purified beta-carotene from capsules, and 2) equal
intake of beta-carotene, whether from carrot, carrot juice or capsule
s, elicits very different serum responses in different individuals.