Self-consisent field Hartree-Fock calculations using MNDO, AM1 and PM3
hamiltonians were carried out for the vibrational spectra of the geom
etrical isomers of the smallest fullerene cluster, C-20 Comparisons wi
th a recent density functional approach brought out similarities and d
ifferences among the methods and were in accord with earlier first pri
nciples stability ordering of the three ground state isomers: the plan
ar cyclic form (the ring), the corannulene form (the bowl), and the cl
osed cage fullerene form. Complete vibrational symmetry assignments ar
e given for the fullerene and the bowl forms and an approximate groupi
ng is presented for the ring isomer. The distribution of all vibration
al levels is compared among the three forms and the density functional
results for the PM3 method, and schematic infrared spectra are calcul
ated for the three C-20 forms.