Md. Porter et Pa. Fricker, CONTROLLED PROSPECTIVE NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT OF ACTIVE EXPERIENCED AMATEUR BOXERS, Clinical journal of sport medicine, 6(2), 1996, pp. 90-96
Objective: To use a practical battery of eight neuropsychological test
s for the detection of an association between amateur boxing and chron
ic traumatic encephalopathy. Design: A controlled prospective neuropsy
chological study over a 15-18-month period. Setting: Dublin, Ireland.
March 1992 to September 1993. Participants: Twenty experienced activel
y competing amateur boxers and 20 controls matched for age and socioec
onomic status. Interventions: Participation in competitive amateur box
ing and training. Main outcome measures: Absolute scores, and changes
in scores, in the neuropsychological tests. Results: At the end of the
study period, the boxers performed significantly better then the cont
rols in both the Trail-Making Tests A and B (TMT-A, TMT-B), whereas th
e control group's scores for the Finger Tapping Tests (FTT) were signi
ficantly higher than those of the boxers. The boxer's scores for the d
ominant-hand FTT showed a significant deterioration, but there was no
association between this change and boxing exposure. Conclusions: Ther
e was no evidence of neuropsychological impairment in the boxers as co
mpared with socioeconomically, educationally and age-matched controls,
and there was no association between boxing exposure and performances
in any of the neuropsychological tests used. There is accumulating ev
idence that amateur boxing is not associated with chronic traumatic en
cephalopathy but longer term prospective studies are needed.