Electronic absorption, fluorescence and fluorescence excitation spectr
a, and vibrational Raman spectra of selected homogeneous solution phas
e, free-base tetraaryl-substituted porphyrins-specifically, tetrapheny
lporphine (TPPH2), tetra(p-pyridyl)porphine (TPyPH(2)), tetra(p-N-meth
ylpyridyl)porphine (TMPyPH(2)), tetra(p-carboxylphenyl)porphine (TCPPH
2), and tetra(p-sulfonatophenyl)porphine (TSPPH2)-as well as their pro
tonated diacids are acquired and analyzed. N-protonation induces a str
uctural change in which the free-base porphyrin is converted from a co
nfiguration in which the aryl moiety is twisted relative to the macroc
ycle plane to one in which it is nearly coplanar, thus promoting aggre
gation. However, spectroscopic investigations of the tetraaryl-substit
uted porphyrins reveal that coplanarity, although necessary, is insuff
icient for aggregation to occur. Also required is that the doubly prot
onated porphyrin have a net zero charge, i.e., be zwitterionic. The st
ructural alignments of monomers in tetraaryl-substituted porphine aggr
egates are suggested to be similar to those of J-aggregates of cyanine
dyes.